‘Working on floppy disks’: FAA has fielded years of warnings about old systems
A CNN investigation reveals how the FAA's nationwide flight shutdown traces back to the same failing infrastructure — and the same contractor — that caused a nearly identical outage 17 years ago.
AI Summary
A CNN review of government oversight reports and past incidents examines how decades of warnings about the FAA's aging air traffic control infrastructure have repeatedly failed to prevent major outages. The most recent nationwide flight halt, caused by a newly installed router in El Dorado, Arkansas during an upgrade by contractor L3Harris, echoes a nearly identical 2009 incident in which a router misconfiguration by the same company's predecessor brought down more than 100 air traffic facilities.
Yank Summary
What matters, in Yank’s words, each linked to where the source says it.
The 2009 FAA outage affected more than 100 air traffic facilities, and a DOT inspector general review found a Harris Corporation technician had 'incorrectly configured' a router. In the source
A 2023 GAO report found more than a third of air traffic control systems were 'unsustainable,' with others heading in the same direction. In the source
We've been working on floppy disks up until a few months ago.
An FAA insider confirms the agency's obsolescence was operational reality until very recently, not merely a theoretical risk.
In context
A spokesperson for Hewlett Packard Enterprise, which owns the manufacturer of the routers in question, said that “based on what we know and have been told by others, our equipment was working as configured.” Regardless of the specific cause of Friday’s breakdown, aviation experts agree the FAA’s systems have become unacceptably outdated. “We’ve been working on floppy disks up until a few months ago,” said Wallace. For decades, decisionmakers failed to proactively invest in timely upgrades, Wallace explained, describing an “if it’s not broken, don’t fix it” mentality that led to the current situation in which some equipment cannot even be replaced because replacement parts no longer exist.
Receipt
The age of the FAA's critical air traffic control systems is so advanced, it makes any private sector comparison difficult.
An official report concludes the FAA's technological decay is so extreme it falls outside any familiar benchmark for comparison.
In context
The report also referenced the agency’s equipment budget and noted more money had been spent sustaining old equipment than acquiring new technology over multiple years. Equipment spotlighted in the report included beacons that were three to five decades old and surveillance technology for which antennas were no longer available. “The age of the FAA’s critical air traffic control systems is so advanced, it makes any private sector comparison difficult,” the report stated. Eric Soskin, a former transportation inspector general, told CNN updating the FAA’s communications system has included inevitable challenges, such as predicting how old and new technologies would work together.
Receipt
For many of its systems, the FAA is no longer able to obtain spare parts. Product lines have been discontinued, manufacturers no longer exist, and the FAA lacks the intellectual property rights to make its own parts.
A 2023 commissioned report documents that the FAA is trapped with unfixable systems because the supply chain supporting them has entirely collapsed.
In context
That reality was detailed in the 2023 independent report commissioned by the FAA. “For many of its systems, the FAA is no longer able to obtain spare parts. Product lines have been discontinued, manufacturers no longer exist, and the FAA lacks the intellectual property rights to make its own parts,” the report found. The report also referenced the agency’s equipment budget and noted more money had been spent sustaining old equipment than acquiring new technology over multiple years. Equipment spotlighted in the report included beacons that were three to five decades old and surveillance technology for which antennas were no longer available.
Receipt
FAA could be prioritizing speed over costs and air traffic disruptions — and if these risks are realized, FAA would need to continue to rely on severely outdated systems prone to failure, leading to more delays and safety incidents.
The GAO warns that rushed upgrades could backfire, leaving the FAA permanently dependent on failure-prone infrastructure.
In context
The report stated the FAA had made progress in replacing thousands of old copper wires with high-speed fiber optic cables but also expressed concern that the agency had not effectively scheduled those replacements to “reduce impacts to controller operations.” “FAA could be prioritizing speed over costs and air traffic disruptions,” stated the GAO report, which added, “If these risks are realized, FAA would need to continue to rely on severely outdated systems that are prone to failure leading to more flight delays and safety incidents.”
FAA could be prioritizing speed over costs and air traffic disruptions stated the GAO report, which added, — and if these risks are realized, FAA would need to continue to rely on severely outdated systems that are prone to failure, leading to more flight delays and safety incidents.
Receipt
I have no money for a new network. I don't have any new money to build new software to separate planes in the air space.
The Transportation Secretary tells the public that existing congressional funding leaves critical network and software needs completely unfunded.
In context
The Trump administration has touted its plans to speedily replace antiquated copper wiring with fiber optics and newer equipment and pointed to Friday’s outage as evidence that Congress needs to provide more than the $12.5 billion already earmarked for upgrades. “Congress did give me $12.5 billion, but they were very specific on how we spend it,” Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said on Sunday. “I have no money for a new network. I don’t have any new money to build new software to separate planes in the air space.”
Receipt
Keep going with this source
Create something
Turn this source into a post, a thread or a newsletter, every line checked against it.
See what you can create →Ask a question
Ask about anything in this article. We’ll try to provide an answer.